All ArticlesNeck Pain

Pinched Nerve in Your Neck: Do You Need Surgery?

For most people with a “pinched nerve” in the neck, surgery is not the first step. A 2026 review of 11 studies found that people did about as well without surgery as with it, for up to about a year. Certain warning signs need prompt medical attention and may mean surgery is needed sooner.

An older bald man with glasses, seen in profile against a dark background, bows his head and holds the back of his neck with one hand.
A pinched nerve in the neck can cause neck pain, arm pain, or both. Photo by Kindel Media on Pexels.

Those warning signs include weakness that keeps getting worse, clumsy hands, and changes in walking or balance. If you notice any of them, get prompt medical care.

If a scan shows a disc pressing on a nerve and a surgeon has recommended surgery, you may be wondering whether waiting is safe. Here is what the recent research says, what it can’t tell us, and when surgery may be needed sooner.

What Is a Pinched Nerve in the Neck?

A “pinched nerve” in the neck, called cervical radiculopathy, happens when a nerve root gets compressed or irritated.[2] A nerve root is where a nerve leaves the spinal cord and heads toward your arm.

The compression or irritation can come from disc material that has pushed out of place, or from bone spurs, which are small bony growths.[2]

Most people feel neck pain, arm pain, or both. Some also notice numbness or tingling, or weakness in the arm or hand.

What Did the Study Find?

People did about as well either way. Kale and colleagues published the review in the journal Spine in 2026.[1] It was a systematic review, which weighs together all the studies it can find on one question.

It included 11 studies with 1,154 people. Of those, 522 had surgery and 632 had non-surgical care.

The researchers compared arm pain, neck pain, disability, use of pain medicine, time off work, and overall success. On every measure, they found no significant difference between the groups.[1] In other words, the review could not tell any gap apart from chance. That is not the same as proving there is no difference.

Dr. Murphy discussed this paper in his “Research Made Real” series. Dr. Murphy notes follow-up ran from about 3 to 12 months, so the results cover up to about a year. He summed it up as “no difference for up to a year.”

How Much Can We Rely on These Results?

Only to a point, and the review was open about it. Researchers rate each study for “risk of bias,” meaning the chance that the way it was run tilted the results. Most of the studies here had a serious risk of bias.[1] In Dr. Murphy’s reading of the paper, that was 8 of the 11.

Overall, the authors rated their confidence in the evidence as moderate, not high.

There are two more limits. The review did not look at what the surgery or the non-surgical care involved. And the authors point out that their results come from selected groups of patients.

The review included real-world (observational) studies as well as trials. In those real-world studies, the treatment was chosen rather than assigned by chance. So the two groups may have differed from the start. That is one reason the authors say the results do not prove the two treatments are equivalent.

In short, people without surgery did about as well for up to about a year. That is not the same as saying the two are interchangeable. Making a decision under the guidance of a respected non-surgical spine specialist such as Dr. Murphy is important.

Dr. Murphy walks through what the review found and how much weight its evidence can carry.

So Should You Try Non-Surgical Care First?

For most people, yes. Dr. Murphy calls comparing non-surgical care and surgery “kind of a moot point,” because, in his view, the real question is what to try first. Care should begin with the least invasive approach, he says, unless there is a clear reason to operate right away, which is “very uncommon.”

What if you don’t get better? If you are not doing well after “an adequate trial of appropriate non-surgical management,” Dr. Murphy says, “then we have the conversation about surgery.”

How long is an adequate trial? There is no fixed rule. The 2016 review says how long to try non-surgical care is unclear.[2] Dr. Murphy usually recommends at least 6 to 8 weeks of appropriate non-surgical management, such as his protocol, before considering surgery unless one of the warning signs arises.

Will waiting make things worse? The same review describes earlier research in which most people improved a lot within 4 to 6 months. That research did not find cases where a pinched nerve went on to cause pressure on the spinal cord.[2]

The same question comes up in the lower back; see our article on lumbar spinal stenosis.

Dr. Murphy explains why non-surgical care usually comes first, and when surgery enters the conversation.

When Might Surgery Be Needed Sooner?

Some signs need prompt medical attention and may mean surgery is needed sooner. A 2016 clinical review lists these:[2]

  • Weakness or other nerve problems that keep getting worse
  • Signs of myelopathy, which means pressure on the spinal cord itself
  • A fracture, or a neck that has become unstable after an injury
  • An abnormal spot in, or destruction of, a spinal bone found on a scan (not ordinary wear and tear or bone spurs)

What to do:

  • After a serious injury such as a fall or car crash, or a possible fracture or unstable neck: get emergency care right away.
  • Weakness that keeps getting worse, clumsy hands, or changes in walking or balance: see a doctor promptly.

Signs of myelopathy include clumsy hands, such as trouble with buttons or handwriting, and changes in how you walk or in your balance. A doctor may also find overly brisk reflexes or other neurological findings on exam.

Does It Matter What Kind of Non-Surgical Care You Get?

Dr. Murphy believes it does. “Not all non-surgical protocols are equal,” he says.

Dr. Murphy applies a structured non-surgical protocol for patients with cervical radiculopathy and his 2006 study showed that to be effective.[3]

Dr. Murphy on why the kind of non-surgical care matters, and what this review could not tell us.

What Should You Do Next?

Before you decide on surgery, get a careful exam and a non-surgical plan from a non-surgical spine specialist you trust, such as Dr. Murphy. Ask the doctor whether any of the warning signs above apply to you. If the doctor advises surgery because of one or more of those signs, take that advice seriously and don’t put it off to try non-surgical care first.

If you are not clearly improving, go back and talk about surgery again; if a warning sign appears, do it right away.

If you are in the Rhode Island area, you can book a visit with Dr. Murphy at Rhode Island Spine Center, or call (401) 702-3269.

Watch the Full Session

Dr. Murphy's full Research Made Real session on surgery versus non-surgical care for a pinched nerve in the neck.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need surgery for a pinched nerve in my neck?

Not for most people. A 2026 review of 11 studies found people did about as well without surgery as with it, for up to about a year. Warning signs such as worsening weakness or signs of pressure on the spinal cord need prompt medical attention. They may mean surgery is needed sooner.

Is surgery better than non-surgical treatment for cervical radiculopathy?

The 2026 review found no significant difference between the two for up to about a year. This covered arm pain, neck pain, disability, pain medicine use, time off work, and overall success. But comparing surgery with non-surgical treatment misses an important point. We should always start with appropriate minimally invasive, non-surgical treatment first. Only if that is not successful (it is successful in most cases) do we even think about trying surgery. Unless, as we’ve discussed, there are uncommon but important warning signs that immediate surgery is necessary.

What signs mean I might need surgery soon?

Warning signs include weakness or other nerve problems that keep getting worse. Signs of pressure on the spinal cord count too, such as clumsy hands, trouble with buttons or handwriting, or changes in walking or balance. A fracture, an unstable neck after an injury, or an abnormal spot in a spinal bone found on a scan can also matter. These need prompt medical attention and may mean surgery is needed sooner. If symptoms started after a serious injury, such as a fall or a car crash, get emergency care right away.

How long should I try non-surgical care?

There is no fixed timeline. Dr. Murphy’s view is that surgery comes up if you are not doing well after an adequate trial of appropriate non-surgical care. A 2016 clinical review says how long to try non-surgical care is unclear. Dr. Murphy usually recommends at least 6 to 8 weeks, and emphasizes the importance of the word ‘appropriate,’ as inappropriate care is not expected to provide benefit.

Does all non-surgical care work equally well?

We don’t know from this research. The 2026 review did not look at what the non-surgical care involved, so it cannot say which approaches help. As Dr. Murphy puts it, not all non-surgical protocols are equal. Dr. Murphy has a well-established protocol for non-surgical management of patients with cervical radiculopathy that he has published and has been following with success for years.[3]


References

  1. Kale KM, Chai YH, Patel S, Nischal SA, Wilson JRF. Nonoperative Management is Associated With Similar Long-Term Patient-Reported Outcomes Compared With Surgery for Cervical Radiculopathy: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Spine. 2026;51(19):E487-E499. PubMed DOI ↩

  2. Iyer S, Kim HJ. Cervical radiculopathy. Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med. 2016;9(3):272-280. PubMed DOI ↩

  3. Murphy DR, Hurwitz EL, Gregory AA, Clary R. A nonsurgical approach to the management of patients with cervical radiculopathy: a prospective observational cohort study. J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 2006;29(4):279-287. ↩

Wondering if This Applies to You?

Dr. Murphy finds the real cause of your pain and builds a treatment plan matched to that cause. If you have been dealing with persistent spine pain, a thorough evaluation is the place to start.

Book a Visit